Off-RoadWeb Homepage Off-Road
Facebook Newsletter

Bike Versus Truck: Who Is Top Dirt Dog?

The Late Jeff “Ox” Kargola Helped Us Choose Our Weapon Before His Last Ride

By Jordan May, Photography by Jordan May, Justin Kosman
Bike Versus Truck Who Is Top Dog Racing

On The Track

During our test day at Glen Helen Raceway, Ox pushed both the bike and truck to their limits. As unbelievable as this may sound, lap after lap, both the truck and bike finished with the exact same time, 53.1 seconds. Dirt Rider Editor Jimmy Lewis took a turn around the track on the bike to see how we would compare to Ox, finishing with an impressive time of 53.2 seconds. His time behind the wheel of the SuperLite was around 20 seconds behind Ox, but in his defense, Jimmy is a bike guy first and foremost.

Both the bike and truck had advantages and disadvantages on the short course track. The bike accelerated quicker through the flat sections and whoops but did suffer from its suspension being set up for Baja, resulting in a lack of stability coming through turns. Having four tires on the ground helped the truck drift through corners with ease and being setup for this terrain, the truck did not suffer any suspension-packing issues, soaring over each jump. In the end, the bike slightly outran the truck into the turns, where the truck caught the bike every time.

Ownership Rights

As much as we begged, Jeff didn’t let us take his SuperLite or CRF450X home for the weekend. So, we don’t feel it would be fair to talk about how each of these machines did away from the track. Having owned both bikes and trucks over the years, we can assemble a list of what we think are the good and bad points of owning both vehicles for the average Joe. To be fair, we chose the same number of each for both even though we could think of another 10 reasons why we love trucks.

We staged a flat drag race to see which would win in a straight line. The bike has a slight power-to-weight advantage. Having better traction off the line and with the rider’s ability to shift the overall weight dramatically, the bike clearly won this battle.
We staged a flat drag race to see which would win in a straight line. The bike has a sligh

Dirt Bike: Pros & Cons

  • + Lightweight machine that can go anywhere if you have the skills
  • + Lower initial cost versus a truck
  • + Easy transport
  • + Less maintenance
  • + Cheaper to race
  • - You are more likely to get injured
  • - Takes more time getting suited up, even for short rides
  • - Riding alone is not advised
  • - Need to constantly watch out for much larger vehicles on the trail
  • - A small problem could stop your entire ride

Prerunner Truck: Pros & Cons

  • + In addition to safety belts, race seats, and a helmet, you’re surrounded by a rollcage
  • + You can take friends for a ride
  • + Easy to carry additional fuel and supplies for long excursions
  • + Possible to drive your truck to the desert and back
  • + Air conditioning and heater
  • - Higher cost of maintenance and fuel consumption
  • - Initial build cost can be very high
  • - Expensive to race
  • - Can be difficult to work on
  • - Tow cost if you break down
  • Power to Weight Showdown

    After the day concluded we were curious about power-to-weight ratio and if that was the reason the bike kept pulling away from the truck in the flat. The bike did end up with a slight advantage, but not by much.

    SuperLite truck weight: 2,550 pounds
    SuperLite truck horsepower: 250 hp
    JCR/Honda CRF450X bike weight: 279 pounds
    JCR/Honda CRF450X bike horsepower: 56 hp
    Jeff “Ox” Kargola weight: 200 pounds
    Truck power to weight ratio: 0.0909 hp/lb
    Bike power to weight ratio: 0.1169 hp/lb

    Curious what the bike guys had to say? Head out to your favorite newsstand and pick up the September issue of Dirt Rider. We have a new found respect for our bike friends. We first thought the short-course truck would make short work of the bike on the track. We’ll still choose a truck on any given day, but it wouldn’t be horrible to have a bike in tow as backup.

    • The SuperLite flew through corners with ease, never needing to let up on the throttle. Having four tires on the ground is a clear advantage for the truck.
      The SuperLite flew through corners with ease, never needing to let up on the throttle. Hav
    • After the day was done, Jeff pulled out his trick bike and put on a show. Not many guys can compete at top level in so many disciplines. The Metal Mulisha guys came out with their ramps so we could watch Jeff do an assortment of tricks we don’t know the names of. One trick that stuck in our heads was the “Superman seat grab.” Jeff truly was a super man.
      After the day was done, Jeff pulled out his trick bike and put on a show. Not many guys ca
    Sources
    General Tire
    1800 Continental Drive
    Charlotte
    NC  28288
    800-847-3349
    www.generaltire.com
    Superlite Champsionship
    9716 South Virgina Street
    Reno
    NV  89511
    1-888-787-3761
    http://www.superlitechampionship
    .com
    JCR Honda
    160 Iglesia
    Suite 103
    San Clemente
    CA  92672
    http://www.jcrhonda.com
    By Jordan May
    Enjoyed this Post? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, or use your favorite social media to recommend us to friends and colleagues!

*Please enter your username

*Please enter your password

*Please enter your comments
Comments:
Not Registered?Signup Here
(1024 character limit)
Off-Road